Death Metal and Girl Shit
← All essays

Essay Eleven: No Safe Place to Become

Home can mean people I miss rather than a place I could return to. Growing up between countries left me thinking about belonging, queer identity, and the safety I needed to understand myself.

I can miss home without being able to name a place I want to go back to. I have a home with my partner and kids, and I love the life we share. There are also people I’d like to have nearby, and an ease I remember having with them, but returning to an address wouldn’t put us back together. Those friends knew the world I grew up in because they’d been there with me. I miss the casualness of it, when seeing each other didn’t need to be a visit. Those are difficult things to give as an answer when someone asks where you’re from. Usually they just want a place name, and I have several that are accurate without any of them quite answering the question.

I grew up as a third-culture kid. In my case, that meant spending part of my childhood outside the country I was considered to be from, among other kids whose lives had also taken them away from theirs. We didn’t share one national background, but we understood something about each other that wasn’t as easy to explain to people who’d stayed where they began. A country could be yours without feeling like the place where people knew you best. Another could contain almost everything you recognised as your life without necessarily being somewhere you’d stay. We were growing up while those distinctions were becoming personal, and we found each other in the middle of it.

There’s affection in how I remember those years. We had our own ways of being ridiculous, and the pleasure of knowing one another well enough that very little explanation was needed. We weren’t solemnly discussing cultural displacement whenever we got together. We were still growing up, and a great deal of our attention went towards music and whatever we thought was funny. I had more in common with those friends than with many of the people I was supposedly going to return home to, but while we were together I didn’t have to do much explaining. I could just enjoy being there.

Going back to my country of origin didn’t bring the sense of reunion the phrase suggested. I wasn’t entirely leaving home or returning to it. The move separated me from the people around whom my social self had developed, and put me somewhere I was expected to find familiar. I could explain where I’d been without being able to convey what it had felt like to grow up there. The people I’d grown up with had been there while I was becoming somebody. Having to introduce myself elsewhere felt different from being known, even when the people I was meeting were perfectly kind.

Finding people who’d lived a similar way helped. I felt less displaced when someone who understood was nearby, without necessarily becoming more attached to the city itself. It was their company I’d needed. But I couldn’t gather everyone I missed into the same place again, and explaining that I was homesick didn’t quite cover it. Somewhere could be anywhere, and in that sense it could also be nowhere. I could feel at home with somebody and still wish several other people were there too.

I learnt to rely on my own sense of who I was because the surroundings weren’t going to hold still long enough to settle it for me. What I cared about didn’t stop being mine when I moved. Neither did the attachments I’d made, however awkward it became to maintain them across distance. I was still a long way from being self-sufficient. I needed the people who understood, and I think we held on to one another partly because so much around us felt beyond our control. Looking inward for continuity didn’t mean I had everything worked out in there. It meant I couldn’t keep asking each new place to explain me.

I knew I was bisexual when I was younger. That was a part of myself I could recognise, even without knowing what to do about it. Understanding who I was attracted to wasn’t the same as feeling able to explore that attraction, and the place where I was growing up didn’t feel safe for it. The same was true of investigating my gender, although I understood much less about what there was to investigate. I had people I loved, but that didn’t give me confidence about how the world beyond those relationships would respond.

It leaves me with an uncomfortable attachment to the place where I grew up. I associate it with people I still love and with feeling unable to investigate important parts of myself. The fear sits inside memories I’m otherwise fond of, rather than in some separate period I can be glad is over. I can miss being there with those people without wishing for all the conditions of that life back. Sometimes it’s difficult to explain what I’m homesick for without sounding as though I want to return to everything I was trying to get through.

Gender was harder to recognise than sexuality, although not because the thoughts were absent. I’d assumed for as long as I could remember that every boy probably would’ve preferred to be a girl. It seemed like an ordinary preference, one of those things people must simply learn to live with. I didn’t understand why it would tell me something different about myself if everyone else felt it too. There were inklings, but I could fit them into that explanation, and the explanation didn’t require me to ask what I might need to change. In a world where examining those feelings didn’t seem especially safe, an answer that let me carry on was very easy to keep.

Imagine sitting with your friends while everyone drinks a glass of water. The glasses look alike, and you have no reason to think yours contains anything different. You know how it tastes and how you feel after drinking it, but you don’t know what anyone else is experiencing. What you can’t see is that yours is salt water, and it’s slowly killing you. Everyone else seems able to keep drinking, so you keep going too. You assume the unpleasantness is something they manage better, or that they simply don’t talk about it. You never think to ask whether the water itself is different, because as far as you can tell you’re all doing the same thing.

That’s how I understand the assumption I was making about being a boy. I could feel the longing and still have no idea that it wasn’t an inevitable part of everyone else’s life. I thought they were dealing with their version of it, and I had to deal with mine. The salt in that comparison is the harm of living without understanding or being able to respond to what I needed, not my gender or sexuality. I didn’t need to stop being queer. I needed some way to discover that the experience I was enduring wasn’t the only one available.

I was accustomed to missing things. Being separated from people I loved explained some of the sadness, while growing up between countries helped account for the difficulty I had feeling settled. Those explanations were true as far as they went. I think they also made it easier to accept a more persistent discomfort as part of the same experience. I couldn’t have told you where missing my friends ended and another kind of longing began. I didn’t have those feelings neatly separated inside me, and I didn’t always have the words to ask anyone to help me distinguish them.

There is a particular exhaustion in feeling that you ought to be more at ease than you are. I could enjoy my friends, care about what we were doing, and still feel an ache I couldn’t account for afterwards. Knowing I’d had a good time didn’t make the sadness dishonest, but it made it harder to explain to myself. I had people, interests, things I genuinely wanted to do. The longing could coexist with all of that, which made it easy to underestimate how much of my life it occupied. It was there on days I would’ve described as good. It was there when I had nothing particular to complain about. Sometimes I was just fucking tired of feeling it, and couldn’t have explained what I wanted someone to make better.

That expectation lasted into adulthood, alongside a life I genuinely loved. My partner and I built a family, and the time I spend with them and our kids belongs in this story just as much as the people and places I miss. I was happy with them before I understood what else I needed. The ache wasn’t evidence that their love was insufficient, and it wasn’t something they should have been able to fix by loving me harder. When I wish I’d understood myself sooner, I’m not wishing away the family we made in those years. I’m wishing I’d been able to feel more at ease with myself while I was there with them.

I wish I’d been able to be uncertain more openly. I would’ve liked to ask what other people felt without worrying so much about what the question might reveal about me. Discovering that they didn’t all share my preference for being a girl might not have produced an immediate answer. I could still have been frightened and unsure what to do, but at least I’d have been considering my own experience instead of assuming it was an inconvenience everybody else had accepted. I feel sad for how long that distinction remained unavailable to me, and angry that safety had so much to do with whether I could examine it at all.

I don’t blame my friends for the things we didn’t understand. They were growing up too, and we knew how to offer each other company without necessarily knowing how to address everything that hurt. I remember being loved as well as being lonely, and being proud of the life we were managing to make together. Some of those friendships lasted through moves and changes none of us could have anticipated when we met. I don’t want to remember that care as inadequate because it couldn’t undo the circumstances around us. It gave me people to return to, and the relief of not having to become a stranger every time my address changed.

Growing up between countries wasn’t what made me trans or bisexual. It influenced how I understood belonging, and what I did when the descriptions available to me didn’t fit very well. I learnt to depend on an internal sense of myself, but I also learnt to tolerate a great deal of not feeling settled. Transition has made me reconsider that tolerance. There are things I no longer have to accept as permanent discomforts, and I’m still getting used to finding that out. I don’t need to dismiss the ways I coped to admit I’d have preferred not to need them.

The happiness I have now makes me feel the length of that earlier longing more clearly. There are things I can say plainly that would’ve been difficult even to consider then. Sometimes the ease of saying them brings home how much effort went into leaving them unexamined. I would’ve liked more ordinary time with the people I loved while feeling able to discover myself. I miss the possibility of that combination. Being glad I can have more of it now doesn’t make me stop wishing it had been available sooner.

Home still means people to me, and my partner and kids are part of what I mean every time I say that. I still miss friends I can’t see as easily as I once did, but I don’t need to feel any less at home with my family to wish those friends were closer. I’m making a life where I can tell the people I love what I’m discovering about myself before I’ve worked out what it means, and I’d like to offer that same patience in return. I want to keep getting to know my partner and watching our kids become themselves, as well as knowing the friends who remember where I began. There’s room for all of that in the life I’m glad to be living.

Leave a little noise

Did this resonate?

Pull up a chair

Join the conversation

Pseudonyms welcome. Be kind; comments appear immediately and may be moderated.

Loading the conversation…

Share

Share a passage as artwork

Share a piece

I can miss home without being able to name a place I want to go back to.
Preview the artwork