During a tournament one of my kids was playing in, I spent the gaps between matches asking ChatGPT to examine my writing for indications that I was trans. My wife was there too. We were out together as a family, and I was trying to work out whether I could trust myself with something that might change how that family understood me. I asked about Bayesian inference, language analysis, different ways of classifying the same material. There is something absurd about trying to establish your gender between rounds of a game, but I wasn’t finding it especially fucking funny. I wanted to know for sure before I told her.
I kept changing the questions. What happened if the technical conversations were included? Could we separate what I’d written about my own life from what I’d invented for fiction? Would a different kind of model arrive at a different conclusion? I didn’t want a few conveniently chosen passages to account for the whole result, I wanted to find the weakness in the explanation before I asked anyone I loved to live with its consequences. Analysis gave me something to do with the fear, and there was always another distinction I could ask it to consider.
The percentages I got back were illustrative estimates, not findings from a trained, validated system. I can’t put them in this story as proof of my gender. What they show me, looking back, is how badly I wanted a number to make this less frightening. I was asking for certainty in a form I knew how to discuss, while struggling to say what I wanted in language that would make it personal. A classification could be questioned without my wife having to answer me. That made it considerably easier to ask for another one.
At one point, I asked which model would give me the strongest case for being cisgender, for not being trans at all. I wanted the alternative examined properly, because I was afraid of mistaking a compelling explanation for the right one. I could imagine how awful it would be to tell her something this consequential and then discover I’d misunderstood myself. I didn’t want to make our lives harder because I’d been careless with a question I should’ve considered more thoroughly. The trouble was that I couldn’t work out how thorough would ever feel like enough, so I kept looking for something else to test.
When I say I was afraid of blowing up my fucking life, I mean a life I wanted to keep. My wife and kids weren’t reasons I’d failed to become myself, they were people I loved being with, and I was frightened of damaging something precious to all of us. I didn’t want to leave them behind for an imaginary future in which I could finally be happy. There was already happiness here. What I couldn’t establish was whether I could ask for something more for myself without making the people closest to me feel that what we’d shared hadn’t been enough.
The world outside our family made the prospect worse. I’d been watching how trans women were talked about and treated, and being visibly trans frightened me. I could picture strangers making decisions about me before I was ready to. This transition was one that needed to be done in public. There is no waiting until you’re ready to step out into the light. I didn’t know what my face or body would look like if I transitioned, or how much privacy I’d have once I did. Realising that those were questions about my future gave the news a different significance. I wasn’t considering an identity in isolation. I was trying to imagine being the person people were talking about, and still being able to get on with my life.
That made certainty feel like a responsibility. If there were consequences for my family as well as for me, surely I ought to be absolutely sure before doing anything. I could be very persuasive with myself about that. The questions sounded careful, and some of them were worth asking. But no amount of confidence about my gender could tell me how my wife would feel, how my body would respond, or how I’d be treated. I was trying to establish something about myself while also asking it to guarantee what would happen afterwards. I didn’t experience those as separate problems. They were all reasons I was scared to speak.
There was another way I was approaching the question during that period, although I hadn’t begun it as an investigation of myself. I was writing a horror novel. I’d become frustrated with stories in which a trans person’s body or identity supplied the horror, and I wanted a trans woman to be the person the reader cared about instead. There could still be something ancient and appalling involved. I wasn’t proposing to rehabilitate the eldritch abomination. I just wanted the woman dealing with it to be allowed to exist without her gender becoming another unpleasant revelation for the audience.
I told my wife what I wanted to write. She encouraged me, offered to read it, and warned that exploring this might bring up things I wouldn’t be able to put aside again. I wasn’t certain why the story had become so important to me, or how much of myself I recognised in the woman I was imagining. I knew I wanted to write her. At that stage, that was easier to explain than what I might want for myself. My wife gave me room to keep writing without requiring me to settle the personal questions before I could begin the next chapter.
The woman in the story sought a transformation through an eldritch bargain. She wanted a body in which she could recognise herself, in a world that enforced conformity and erased people who didn’t fit. Writing that gave me somewhere to consider what recognition could be worth to somebody, and how much fear could surround wanting it. I could follow her choices and think about their consequences without yet knowing how closely they resembled anything I would choose. There was enough distance in fiction for me to keep going, even while I was writing about feelings that were becoming difficult to leave on the page.
Eventually, she was offered her former body and a supposedly easier existence. She refused. I’d written a woman who had experienced the change she wanted and wasn’t prepared to surrender it simply because surrender might make her life less difficult. I could understand her answer well enough to write it, although that didn’t give me the same confidence about my own future. She’d already had an experience I was still trying to imagine. I couldn’t borrow her certainty just because I was the one who’d put it into words.
I hadn’t set out to hide a confession in a manuscript for my wife to discover. Writing about a character doesn’t make her story autobiographical, and I wasn’t sure how much of this woman’s experience I shared, but I could explain why she wanted the transformation and why she refused to give it back, even when explaining my own feelings remained difficult. My wife was reading those pages with knowledge of me that no imagined reader had.
After reading that part, she asked whether the feelings in it were how I felt. She was concerned that not transitioning, if these were my feelings, could eventually do me terrible harm. She didn’t tell me who I was, she wanted us to stop avoiding a conversation whose absence was becoming painful, and she gave me the nudge I needed to have it. We’d shared a life for years, and here was something I’d been frightened to explain to her appearing in a story I’d asked her to read.
I find that part difficult to describe without making her sound like she possessed an answer I’d somehow failed to notice. She didn’t need to know my gender better than I did to recognise that I was struggling. She knew me well enough to be concerned, and cared enough to ask a question that neither of us could answer on the other’s behalf. We sat down and talked. I didn’t arrive with every uncertainty resolved, or with the future made safe by whatever I’d managed to say about it in a chat. She was willing to hear me before I could offer her that kind of confidence.
In the statistical conversation, I eventually wrote, “I think I’m looking at an answer I already have.” I can recognise that admission without pretending it ended the struggle. I was beginning to acknowledge something about myself, but I was still afraid of what acknowledging it might ask of me. That’s why the manuscript and the analysis both belong in how I remember this. I could give a fictional woman room to want something, ask a machine to examine my own words, and still need help talking to the person whose response I most wanted and feared.
I did come out, and my wife stayed beside me. Her support has been something I’ve lived with since, rather than the disaster I’d been trying so hard to rule out in advance. I’m deeply grateful for that, but it doesn’t make the earlier fear ridiculous. I didn’t have our later conversations available to reassure me while I was deciding whether I could manage the first ones. I also don’t want to turn her kindness into evidence that anyone else’s coming out will be safe. I can tell you how fortunate I’ve been with her without asking someone in different circumstances to trust a reassurance I can’t offer them.
There wasn’t a point where all the doubt stopped. There hasn’t been since, either. I still sometimes wake up wondering whether I’m doing the right thing, or whether it would be easier not to keep doing it. Sometimes I’m questioning a decision. Sometimes I’m tired of what I expect from the world and want a day that doesn’t demand quite so much of me. I don’t always separate those feelings neatly while I’m having them, and I don’t want to edit that uncertainty out now to make the woman at the tournament look as though she was steadily approaching a permanent answer.
There are times I wish I’d been cisgender, because I’d have liked to feel aligned with my body without having to work so hard for it, and without worrying about what people make of that work. It doesn’t even resolve into a simple wish that I’d been born a cis woman. I can imagine wanting the ease of being a cis man too, if that had meant being comfortable with who I was. The comfort is what I’m wishing for. I didn’t get to choose that starting point, and wishing it had been simpler doesn’t tell me what to do with the life I actually have.
In that life, I’m in love with the human I am. I can say that with a sincerity I would’ve struggled to predict while I was asking for another classification. It doesn’t make me immune to being frightened, or mean every question I ask myself now is secretly settled. It means there is also affection here, pleasure in being this person, and a wish to keep sharing her life with the people she loves. I don’t have to discount those feelings because they didn’t arrive as a proof. They are part of what I have to consider, just as the fear is.
The tournament stays with me because we were there for our kid, doing something together that belonged to the family we’d already made, while I looked for certainty about a conversation I hoped that family could survive. I still understand why I kept asking. But my wife didn’t need me to finish the analysis before she could care about what was happening to me. She read my story, asked about the feelings in it, and we talked. We’re still making our life together now, including the days when I don’t have particularly reassuring answers about how I’m doing. I spent so long trying to be sure before telling her, and it turns out there’s a great deal we can talk about while I’m not.
Sign in to comment